In the world of professional sports, a single moment can change everything. It can turn a routine play into a legendary one, a quiet player into a household name, and a professional career into a cultural phenomenon. For Sophie Cunningham, a forward for the Indiana Fever, that moment came with less than a minute left in a hard-fought game against the Connecticut Sun. It wasn’t a game-winning shot or a spectacular defensive block. It was a hard, intentional foul, a physical act of defiance that became a symbol for a simmering tension that had been building on and off the court all season.

On June 17, the W.N.B.A. game between the Fever and the Sun was characterized by an unmistakable air of hostility. The physicality was cranked up, the fouls were frequent, and the referees seemed unwilling or unable to get control of the game. The main target of the Sun’s aggression was the league’s most talked-about star, Caitlin Clark. Clark, whose unparalleled talent and fame had brought unprecedented attention to the league, had been subjected to hard fouls all season, and on this night, the physicality was at an all-time high. She had been shoved by one player and poked in the eye by another. For Cunningham, a player known for her own fiery temperament, it was too much. She felt that her teammate, the player whose presence had elevated everyone on the roster, was not being properly protected. She wanted to send a message.

With the game winding down, the perfect opportunity arose. As Sun player Jacy Sheldon stole the ball and sprinted toward the basket, Cunningham raced after her and, in a deliberate and decisive move, wrapped her arms around Sheldon, pulling her to the hardwood. The foul was immediate, flagrant, and unmistakable. It was also a lightning rod. Sheldon and another Sun player, Lindsay Allen, rushed toward Cunningham, enraged by the act. The three players were quickly ejected, but the damage was done. In that singular moment, Cunningham had a new identity. She was no longer just a player on the team; she was the enforcer, the protector, the teammate who was willing to get ejected to stand up for her friend.

The fallout was instantaneous and dramatic. The foul became an overnight sensation, a viral clip shared and debated across every social media platform. Within days, Cunningham’s follower count on Instagram and TikTok skyrocketed, jumping from a few hundred thousand to well over a million. Her inbox was flooded with messages from fans cheering her on, calling her a hero. The energy at subsequent games shifted; crowds cheered her enthusiastically, while opposing fans booed her with equal fervor. She had become a symbol, a new kind of star in a league hungry for compelling personalities.

To Cunningham, the act was simple. “I didn’t do that for clickbait,” she said in an interview, pushing back against the idea that the move was calculated for fame. “I stand up for my teammates.” Her sister echoed a similar sentiment, stating that growing up, Cunningham had been taught the art of defending her friends and herself. But whether it was intentional or not, the incident created a tidal wave of financial opportunities. Her representatives at PRP, a sports agency, moved quickly. The day after the foul, an executive at PRP called the chief executive of Ring, the home security company, and pitched Cunningham as a “protector.” The pitch was successful, and within two weeks, Cunningham posted a paid advertisement for Ring on her TikTok. This was just one of seven new deals she secured in the weeks after the incident, deals that also included Arby’s.

For a player making a W.N.B.A. salary of around $100,000 this year, this financial windfall was staggering. The money she will earn from these sponsorships will reportedly dwarf her basketball earnings. It’s a testament to the new reality of women’s sports in the digital age. Unlike their male counterparts, who have long benefited from massive league promotions and television contracts, female athletes have had to take control of their own narratives, becoming their own best marketing tools. As one professor of sports communication, Cara Hawkins-Jedlicka, noted, female athletes are “having to lean in” on social media because they don’t receive as much promotion from traditional media outlets. Cunningham’s viral moment was a perfect storm, a single action that allowed her to tap into a market and a conversation that was already happening.

That conversation, however, was not just about basketball. It was also deeply political. The treatment of Caitlin Clark on the court had become a cause célèbre for right-leaning pundits, who framed her treatment as a racial issue. They argued, often without evidence, that Clark was being targeted because she is a white woman. This narrative, already popular in conservative circles, found a new hero in Cunningham. Fans who saw her as the enforcer began calling her “MAGA Barbie,” a politically charged nickname that drew on her appearance and the conservative “Make America Great Again” slogan. The conservative sports site OutKick, for instance, praised Cunningham, with one writer saying she “might be a Big R Republican, which certainly doesn’t hurt.”

Cunningham, for her part, has tried to distance herself from the political fray. She describes her politics as “right in the middle,” stating, “I agree with things on both sides; I disagree with things on both sides.” She insists that she’s not an extremist and that in today’s culture, there’s an unfortunate pressure to choose a side. But her actions and her brand have resonated with a political audience, regardless of her intentions. She’s active with the players’ union in its fight for better pay, a cause that aligns more with the left, yet she also follows prominent conservative social media accounts. This duality, however, hasn’t seemed to hurt her popularity. Her willingness to take a stand, whether on the court or in the media, has made her a compelling figure to a large, diverse, and often divided audience.

And that is her ultimate brand. Cunningham has leaned into being an edgy, authentic personality. She has been fined by the W.N.B.A. for criticizing referees on her podcast, she’s openly showed off her chipped front tooth and a misshapen finger—casualties of her physical style of play—and she has even posted glibly about the sex toys that were thrown onto W.N.B.A. courts. Her unapologetic style has become her superpower. As she said, she’s not going to pretend to be anything she’s not. This realness, this willingness to be a little rough around the edges, is what has made her a new kind of celebrity. It’s what drives ratings, and it’s what draws a massive audience.

In the end, Sophie Cunningham’s story is a fascinating case study in the modern sports landscape. She was a player who was already on a rising team, and her trade to the Fever put her on a “rocket ship.” But her on-court actions, whether a righteous defense of a teammate or a calculated act of self-promotion, positioned her perfectly to take advantage of the W.N.B.A.’s newfound popularity and its complex cultural divides. The foul she committed was more than just a play. It was a signal, a political act, and a personal branding masterclass. And as the W.N.B.A. continues to grow, navigating the complexities of fame and politics, Cunningham stands as an example of what it means to be a star in this new era